SEC's Recommendation on Coinbase Rulemaking Proposal Sparks Uncertainty

Table of Contents

“Coinbase Rulemaking Proposal: SEC’s Recommendation Raises More Questions Than Answers”

The legal battle between Coinbase and the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has taken a significant turn as the SEC issued recommendations concerning Coinbase’s rulemaking proposal, a crucial component of their enforcement action.

Paul Grewal, Coinbase’s Chief Legal Officer, revealed that the SEC had reached out to the third court regarding Coinbase’s rulemaking proposal, shedding light on the case’s progress.

SEC Recommendations in Coinbase’s Legal Battle

On October 10th, SEC staff submitted proposals to the Commission, following Coinbase’s mandatory request for submission in April 2023, seeking a swift response to their rulemaking proposal’s opposition submitted in July. The court granted the SEC 120 days to respond. While Coinbase’s Chief Legal Officer expressed gratitude for this latest step, further details regarding the recommendations are still needed.

The update should provide a formal, public response to Coinbase’s rulemaking proposal while keeping the timing of the SEC’s decision undisclosed.

Grewal also expressed disappointment with the SEC’s delay in providing a definitive response and urged the SEC to communicate its decision timeline to the court. He stated, “Today, the SEC provided an update as ordered by the court in the Coinbase enforcement case: yesterday, SEC staff made some recommendations to the Commission about our rulemaking proposal.

That’s it. That’s the entire update. We are grateful for the court’s inspiring this small step. But a formal, public response to this proposal is overdue. And with the ongoing crypto enforcement campaign, at the very least, the SEC should inform the court of its decision timeline. Please don’t kick the can down the road any further.”

>>> How Previous Halvings Impact Bitcoin’s 2024 Halving Event?

State Regulatory Body Supports SEC

On October 10th, the North American Securities Administrators Association (NASAA), representing state and provincial securities regulatory agencies across North America, submitted a support summary to the SEC in the ongoing case against Coinbase.

NASAA, comprising regulatory bodies from the United States, Canada, and Mexico, has a longstanding mission to protect investors from fraud and market abuses in the securities industry.

However, some cryptocurrency proponents argue that NASAA’s support for the SEC in this case reflects a broader bias against the cryptocurrency industry, overlooking its potential benefits and hindering its progress.

Critics contend that NASAA views digital assets as a significant threat to investors and fails to acknowledge the strides made in implementing robust security measures and industry compliance. In recent years, reputable cryptocurrency exchanges, including Coinbase, have introduced stringent Know Your Customer (KYC) and Anti-Money Laundering (AML) procedures to enhance security and prevent illicit activities.

As the lawsuit against Coinbase unfolds, it raises crucial questions about the future of cryptocurrency regulations. Striking the right balance between investor protection and fostering innovation is crucial to ensure the long-term success of the industry.